Assessing Water Quality Parameters: Computational Methods
Importance of Water Quality Monitoring
Water quality monitoring is essential for protecting both public health and the environment. It involves assessing the condition of water bodies such as rivers, lakes, and oceans, ensuring that they are safe for consumption, recreation, and support healthy ecosystems. Poor water quality can lead to various health risks, including waterborne diseases, contamination, and the loss of biodiversity. Regular monitoring helps in detecting contaminants early, ensuring water safety, and informing effective water management policies.
Role of Computational Methods in Water Quality Assessment
Computational methods play a crucial role in modern water quality assessment by providing efficient, cost-effective, and accurate ways to monitor and predict water conditions. These methods utilize advanced algorithms, machine learning, and data analytics to process large datasets from various sensors and environmental monitoring systems. They help in the early detection of pollution, predicting future water quality trends, and supporting real-time decision-making for water management. By integrating computational models with real-time data, researchers and authorities can enhance water quality management and make informed decisions to safeguard water resources.
Key Water Quality Parameters
Physical Parameters (Temperature, Turbidity, etc.)
Physical parameters are the most straightforward indicators of water quality. They include characteristics such as:
- Temperature: Water temperature affects the rate of chemical reactions, oxygen solubility, and the overall health of aquatic organisms.
- Turbidity: This refers to the cloudiness or haziness of water caused by the presence of suspended particles. High turbidity levels can reduce light penetration, affecting photosynthesis in aquatic plants.
- Color: The color of water can indicate the presence of organic materials, pollutants, or algae.
- Conductivity: This measures the ability of water to conduct electricity, which can be affected by the concentration of dissolved ions in the water.
Chemical Parameters (pH, Dissolved Oxygen, Heavy Metals, etc.)
Chemical parameters are essential for understanding the chemical composition of water and its suitability for various uses. These parameters include:
- pH: The pH level indicates the acidity or alkalinity of the water. Extreme pH levels can harm aquatic life and disrupt ecological balance.
- Dissolved Oxygen (DO): Oxygen dissolved in water is crucial for the survival of fish and other aquatic organisms. Low levels of DO can lead to hypoxic conditions, stressing aquatic life.
- Heavy Metals: Toxic heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and arsenic can be harmful to both human health and aquatic ecosystems, even in low concentrations.
- Nutrient Levels: Excess nutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorus, can lead to eutrophication, causing algal blooms and oxygen depletion in water bodies.
Biological Parameters (Microbial Contamination, Algal Bloom, etc.)
Biological parameters help assess the presence of organisms in the water that can affect its quality and safety:
- Microbial Contamination: Pathogenic microorganisms, such as bacteria, viruses, and protozoa, can contaminate water, making it unsafe for drinking and recreational activities.
- Algal Bloom: Excessive growth of algae due to high nutrient levels can reduce water quality, deplete oxygen, and produce toxins harmful to aquatic life and human health.
- Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD): BOD measures the amount of oxygen consumed by microorganisms in the water. High BOD levels indicate pollution, as it suggests a high concentration of organic matter.
Traditional Methods of Water Quality Testing
Laboratory Techniques
Laboratory techniques are often the most accurate methods for testing water quality, involving the collection of water samples that are analyzed in a controlled environment. Some of the key laboratory techniques include:
- Gravimetric Analysis: Used to determine the concentration of suspended solids in water by weighing the material after filtration.
- Chemical Titration: A process where a chemical reagent is added to a water sample to determine the concentration of specific substances, such as chlorine or dissolved oxygen.
- Spectrophotometry: This technique measures the amount of light absorbed by water samples at specific wavelengths, helping to quantify contaminants such as metals and nutrients.
- Microbiological Testing: Used to detect harmful microorganisms, such as bacteria and viruses, that may pose a health risk to humans.
Field-based Methods
Field-based methods allow for the direct collection and testing of water samples in real-time, often at the site of water bodies. These methods are more practical for continuous monitoring and provide immediate data. Key field-based methods include:
- Portable Sensors: Devices such as pH meters, turbidity sensors, and dissolved oxygen probes can be used on-site to measure key parameters instantly.
- Test Strips: Chemical test strips are commonly used for rapid testing of various water quality parameters, including pH, chlorine, and hardness.
- Mobile Laboratories: Some field laboratories are equipped with essential tools and instruments to conduct a range of tests in the field, reducing the time between sampling and analysis.
Limitations of Conventional Approaches
While traditional methods are effective, they also have several limitations that may hinder their application in large-scale or real-time water quality monitoring:
- Time-Consuming: Laboratory analysis often requires a significant amount of time to process samples, making it unsuitable for real-time monitoring.
- Costly: Both laboratory testing and field-based methods can be expensive, especially when frequent or widespread testing is required.
- Limited Spatial Coverage: Traditional methods may not be able to cover large or remote areas effectively, resulting in limited data on water quality across vast regions.
- Inaccuracies: Human error, instrument calibration, and sample contamination can lead to inaccuracies in test results, especially when performed by non-experts.
- Environmental Conditions: Some methods, such as field-based testing, can be influenced by environmental conditions such as temperature and weather, affecting the reliability of results.
Computational Methods in Water Quality Assessment
Overview of Computational Techniques
Computational techniques in water quality assessment utilize advanced algorithms, models, and data analytics to interpret large datasets, often collected from multiple sensors or monitoring systems. These methods enable efficient analysis, prediction, and management of water quality, offering faster and more accurate insights compared to traditional approaches. The integration of computational tools enhances the understanding of complex water systems and allows for better-informed decision-making in water resource management and pollution control.
Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence in Water Quality
Machine learning (ML) and artificial intelligence (AI) have become essential tools in water quality monitoring and prediction. These techniques are capable of identifying complex patterns in large datasets and making predictions based on historical data. Key applications include:
- Predictive Modeling: ML algorithms such as regression analysis and support vector machines (SVM) can predict future water quality trends by analyzing past data.
- Anomaly Detection: AI can identify unusual changes in water quality, such as sudden spikes in pollutants, providing early warnings of potential contamination events.
- Classification: AI techniques, like decision trees or neural networks, can classify water bodies based on quality status, distinguishing between safe, moderately polluted, or heavily contaminated waters.
- Real-time Monitoring: AI-powered systems can continuously analyze data from sensors, enabling real-time detection of contaminants and rapid responses to water quality changes.
Data-Driven Approaches
Data-driven approaches rely on the use of vast amounts of collected data to model and assess water quality without the need for predefined physical or chemical models. These methods often involve:
- Big Data Analytics: By processing large datasets from multiple sources, such as satellites, sensors, and environmental databases, data-driven methods provide comprehensive insights into water quality trends over time and space.
- Remote Sensing: Satellite imagery and drone-based sensors can collect data over large areas, which is then analyzed through computational methods to assess water quality on a regional scale.
- Data Fusion: This technique combines data from various sources (e.g., sensors, satellite imagery, and weather data) to create a more accurate and comprehensive understanding of water quality conditions.
- Data Mining: By applying advanced algorithms to existing datasets, data mining techniques can uncover hidden relationships and patterns in water quality data, improving decision-making processes.
Modeling Water Quality Parameters
Statistical Modeling
Statistical modeling is widely used to analyze water quality data and identify relationships between different parameters. By applying statistical techniques, it is possible to determine correlations and trends that can provide valuable insights into water quality changes. Some common approaches include:
- Regression Analysis: This method helps to understand the relationship between various water quality parameters (e.g., pH, turbidity, and temperature) and other environmental factors. It can also be used to predict values of unmeasured parameters based on known data.
- Correlation Analysis: Statistical correlation techniques can be employed to determine how strongly different water quality parameters are related to one another, assisting in identifying key factors affecting water quality.
- Time Series Analysis: Time series models are used to analyze changes in water quality over time, which helps in understanding seasonal variations, long-term trends, and the impact of specific events or interventions.
Predictive Modeling
Predictive modeling in water quality assessment focuses on using historical data to forecast future water quality conditions. This approach is particularly valuable for proactive management and decision-making. Predictive modeling techniques include:
- Machine Learning Algorithms: Algorithms such as Random Forest, Neural Networks, and Support Vector Machines (SVM) can predict future water quality based on historical data and environmental variables. These models are trained to recognize patterns and make accurate predictions.
- Dynamic Simulation Models: These models simulate the behavior of water bodies over time, taking into account various physical, chemical, and biological processes that influence water quality. They are used for long-term predictions and the assessment of management strategies.
- Artificial Neural Networks (ANN): ANNs are capable of modeling complex, non-linear relationships between different water quality parameters and external factors, providing highly accurate predictions even in systems with large amounts of noise and uncertainty.
Geospatial Modeling for Water Quality Mapping
Geospatial modeling involves the use of geographic information systems (GIS) and spatial analysis tools to map and visualize water quality data. This approach helps in understanding the spatial distribution of water quality parameters and identifying problem areas that require attention. Key techniques include:
- Spatial Interpolation: This technique uses data collected from specific locations to estimate water quality parameters across a larger area. Common methods like Kriging or Inverse Distance Weighting (IDW) help to predict values in areas where measurements are lacking.
- Remote Sensing: Satellite imagery and aerial sensors are used to collect spatial data on water quality, such as turbidity, chlorophyll concentration, and surface temperature. These data are then integrated into geospatial models to monitor large-scale water quality changes.
- Hotspot Detection: Geospatial analysis can identify water quality "hotspots" by mapping areas with particularly high or low levels of pollutants, allowing authorities to target remediation efforts more effectively.
- Environmental Modelling: Coupled with GIS, environmental models can simulate the transport and dispersion of pollutants across watersheds, helping to predict the impact of land use, industrial activities, and other factors on water quality in different regions.
Sensors and Data Collection for Computational Methods
Types of Sensors for Water Quality
Sensors are essential tools for collecting data on water quality parameters. They provide real-time measurements of various water characteristics and enable continuous monitoring. Common types of sensors used for water quality testing include:
- pH Sensors: These sensors measure the acidity or alkalinity of water, which is crucial for maintaining the health of aquatic ecosystems and ensuring water safety for human consumption.
- Turbidity Sensors: These devices measure the cloudiness or haziness of water caused by suspended particles. High turbidity can indicate contamination and reduce light penetration, affecting aquatic life.
- Dissolved Oxygen (DO) Sensors: DO sensors measure the concentration of oxygen dissolved in water, which is critical for the survival of aquatic organisms. Low DO levels can indicate pollution or eutrophication.
- Temperature Sensors: Water temperature sensors monitor changes in temperature, which can affect chemical reactions, oxygen solubility, and biological processes in water.
- Chlorophyll Sensors: These sensors detect the presence of algae in water bodies by measuring chlorophyll concentration, which is useful for identifying algal blooms and assessing water quality in terms of eutrophication.
- Heavy Metal Sensors: These sensors detect the presence of toxic metals such as lead, mercury, and arsenic, which can contaminate water and pose significant risks to human health and the environment.
Real-Time Data Collection and Monitoring Systems
Real-time data collection systems allow for continuous, up-to-date monitoring of water quality parameters, enabling immediate responses to changes in water conditions. These systems are typically made up of a network of sensors and data acquisition platforms that transmit data to central monitoring stations. Key components include:
- Sensor Networks: A distributed network of sensors placed at various locations in water bodies collects data in real time. These sensors transmit data wirelessly to central databases for analysis.
- IoT-based Monitoring Systems: The Internet of Things (IoT) allows for the integration of sensors into a connected network that facilitates remote monitoring and control of water quality parameters from any location with internet access.
- Automated Sampling Systems: These systems automatically collect water samples at scheduled intervals, reducing the need for manual sampling. They are often paired with sensors for comprehensive data analysis.
- Remote Sensing Systems: Remote sensing technologies, including satellites and drones, can collect water quality data from large areas, particularly for hard-to-reach or vast water bodies. These systems provide timely data on key parameters such as temperature, chlorophyll, and turbidity.
Integration of Sensors with Computational Tools
The integration of sensors with computational tools enhances the capabilities of water quality monitoring by providing a seamless flow of data from sensors to analysis platforms. This integration enables real-time data processing, modeling, and prediction of water quality changes. Key aspects of integration include:
- Data Integration: Sensors collect data in various formats, which are then integrated into centralized platforms for analysis. Advanced data processing algorithms are used to clean, validate, and standardize the data for accurate interpretation.
- Real-time Decision Support Systems: By combining sensor data with computational models, real-time decision support systems can help water quality managers identify trends, detect anomalies, and take immediate actions to address water quality issues.
- Predictive Analytics: Data from sensors can be fed into machine learning models to predict future water quality conditions, helping to anticipate pollution events or changes in water parameters before they occur.
- Geospatial Integration: Sensor data, when combined with geospatial analysis tools such as GIS, allows for the visualization of water quality parameters across different geographic locations, providing detailed insights into the spatial distribution of contaminants.
- Cloud Computing: Cloud platforms allow for the storage and analysis of large volumes of sensor data from multiple locations, enabling scalable and flexible water quality monitoring across regions or countries.
Applications of Computational Methods in Water Quality Monitoring
Predicting Contaminant Levels
Computational methods are invaluable in predicting contaminant levels in water bodies, providing early warnings and helping authorities take preventive actions. These methods use historical data, environmental variables, and predictive algorithms to forecast future levels of pollutants. Key applications include:
- Machine Learning Models: Machine learning algorithms, such as regression models and neural networks, analyze historical contaminant data to predict future concentrations of pollutants like heavy metals, nitrates, and phosphates.
- Time Series Forecasting: Time series analysis can be applied to historical data to predict future contaminant levels, accounting for seasonal variations and long-term trends in water quality.
- Source Tracking: Computational models can track the sources of pollutants by analyzing data from multiple sensors, identifying the origin of contaminants, and enabling targeted intervention strategies.
Early Detection of Pollution Events
Computational methods can enhance the early detection of pollution events by continuously analyzing data from sensors and identifying anomalies that may indicate a contamination event. Early detection is crucial in mitigating potential environmental and public health risks. Key approaches include:
- Anomaly Detection Algorithms: Machine learning and statistical algorithms can automatically detect unusual patterns in water quality data, signaling potential pollution events such as chemical spills or wastewater discharges.
- Real-time Monitoring: Real-time data collected from sensors allows for the immediate identification of sudden changes in water quality, such as a sudden drop in dissolved oxygen or a spike in turbidity levels, which could indicate contamination.
- Event Detection Systems: By continuously analyzing sensor data, automated systems can flag pollution events as they occur, allowing authorities to respond quickly and minimize the impact on water quality and aquatic life.
Decision Support Systems for Water Management
Decision support systems (DSS) are computational tools that assist water resource managers in making informed decisions about water quality management. These systems integrate real-time data, predictive models, and optimization algorithms to guide decisions on water treatment, pollution control, and resource allocation. Key features include:
- Integrated Data Systems: DSS combine data from various sources, such as water sensors, weather data, and satellite imagery, to provide a comprehensive overview of water quality across a region.
- Scenario Modeling: DSS use computational models to simulate different water management scenarios, such as the impact of pollution control measures or changes in land use, helping decision-makers evaluate the outcomes of various interventions.
- Optimization Algorithms: Optimization techniques can help allocate resources efficiently by identifying the best strategies for water treatment, contamination control, and the management of water supply in response to changing quality conditions.
- Real-time Alerts: DSS can send real-time alerts to water quality managers when critical parameters exceed safe limits, enabling timely interventions to protect public health and aquatic ecosystems.
Challenges and Limitations
Data Quality and Availability
One of the primary challenges in water quality monitoring using computational methods is the availability and quality of data. Inaccurate or incomplete data can lead to erroneous predictions and poor decision-making. Key issues include:
- Sensor Calibration and Maintenance: Sensors used for water quality monitoring require regular calibration and maintenance to ensure accurate data collection. Without proper calibration, data can be distorted, affecting model predictions.
- Data Gaps: In some regions, especially remote areas, there may be insufficient or irregular data collection. This lack of comprehensive data can hinder accurate modeling and analysis.
- Data Integration: Combining data from various sources (e.g., sensors, satellites, and field tests) can be challenging due to differences in formats, measurement units, and temporal resolution, leading to potential inconsistencies and inaccuracies in analysis.
Algorithm Accuracy and Reliability
While computational algorithms are powerful tools for water quality assessment, their accuracy and reliability are critical to ensuring valid results. Challenges in this area include:
- Model Overfitting: Some machine learning models may overfit the data, meaning they perform well on the training data but fail to generalize to new, unseen data. This reduces the reliability of predictions in real-world conditions.
- Data Sensitivity: Computational models can be highly sensitive to the quality and quantity of input data. Small errors or changes in data can lead to significant variations in predictions, making it essential to ensure high-quality, consistent data.
- Complexity of Environmental Systems: Water quality is influenced by numerous complex and interacting factors, such as weather conditions, land use, and pollution sources. Developing accurate models that account for all these factors is difficult, and errors in modeling assumptions can impact the reliability of results.
Environmental Factors Influencing Results
Environmental factors can have a significant impact on the accuracy and effectiveness of water quality monitoring. These factors include:
- Variable Environmental Conditions: Factors such as temperature, rainfall, and seasonal changes can influence water quality parameters. These fluctuations can make it difficult to establish baseline conditions and may require frequent recalibration of models and sensors.
- Non-Uniform Distribution of Contaminants: Pollutants may not be evenly distributed in water bodies, leading to spatial variability that can make monitoring challenging. Incomplete coverage of sensor networks can result in missed contamination events or inaccurate assessments of water quality.
- Interference from External Factors: Environmental factors such as algae blooms, aquatic plants, and sediments can interfere with sensors and alter the measurement of certain parameters, like turbidity or dissolved oxygen, making it harder to obtain accurate readings.
Future Directions
Emerging Technologies in Water Quality Assessment
The future of water quality monitoring is shaped by emerging technologies that promise to enhance data collection, analysis, and decision-making. Some of the most promising technologies include:
- Nanotechnology: Nanomaterials and nanosensors offer increased sensitivity and accuracy for detecting trace pollutants and pathogens in water. These technologies have the potential to revolutionize water quality monitoring by enabling real-time detection of harmful substances at extremely low concentrations.
- Smart Water Sensors: Next-generation smart sensors, equipped with IoT capabilities, will provide more accurate, real-time data and allow for seamless communication between sensors, databases, and decision-making platforms. These sensors will be more adaptable and capable of monitoring multiple water quality parameters simultaneously.
- Remote Sensing and Satellite Imaging: Advances in remote sensing technologies, including high-resolution satellite imagery and drone-based sensors, will provide comprehensive data on water quality across large and hard-to-reach areas. This will improve the ability to monitor water bodies in real time and over extensive geographical areas.
- Biotechnology: The integration of biological sensors, including bioindicators and biosensors, will enable the detection of specific pollutants or microorganisms, providing another layer of precision in water quality assessment.
Advances in Computational Tools
Advancements in computational tools will significantly enhance the accuracy, scalability, and usability of water quality monitoring systems. Key developments include:
- Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning: Continued advancements in AI and machine learning will lead to more sophisticated models for predicting water quality changes, detecting pollution events, and optimizing water management strategies. These tools will become more adaptable, handling larger datasets and providing deeper insights into water quality dynamics.
- Big Data and Cloud Computing: The use of big data analytics combined with cloud computing will enable the processing and storage of vast amounts of water quality data. This will make it easier to scale monitoring systems, share data globally, and facilitate collaborative decision-making.
- Blockchain Technology: Blockchain can be used to ensure the integrity and transparency of water quality data. It will provide secure, immutable records of water quality tests and data collection, helping to build trust among stakeholders and enabling better accountability in water management practices.
- Simulation and Modeling Software: Advances in environmental modeling software will allow for more accurate simulations of water systems, accounting for a wider range of variables and improving the ability to predict the effects of different water management strategies on water quality.
Global Trends and Sustainability in Water Quality Monitoring
As water scarcity and pollution continue to be major global concerns, sustainability in water quality monitoring will be a key focus in the coming years. Global trends that are shaping the future of water quality monitoring include:
- Data Sharing and Open Access: There is a growing trend towards open data sharing in water quality monitoring. By making data accessible to governments, researchers, and the public, more informed decisions can be made to protect water resources and improve global water quality management.
- Global Collaboration: International collaboration on water quality monitoring and management will increase, particularly with regard to shared water bodies and cross-border pollution. Collaborative efforts will ensure that best practices are followed and that resources are allocated effectively.
- Sustainable Water Management: The integration of sustainability practices into water quality monitoring will become more prevalent. Emphasizing the importance of maintaining healthy aquatic ecosystems, reducing pollution, and optimizing the use of water resources will be central to long-term strategies for improving water quality.
- Regulatory and Policy Development: As data from new technologies and computational tools become available, there will be stronger regulatory frameworks and policies in place to address emerging water quality issues. Governments and environmental agencies will increasingly rely on data-driven insights to shape policies that protect water quality for future generations.
Conclusion
Computational methods have revolutionized the way we assess and manage water quality. By leveraging advanced technologies such as machine learning, predictive modeling, and real-time monitoring systems, we can make more informed decisions and take timely actions to protect our water resources. Despite the challenges, including data quality issues, algorithm reliability, and environmental factors, the future of water quality assessment looks promising with the continuous development of new tools and technologies.
Emerging innovations like nanotechnology, AI, and remote sensing are setting the stage for more accurate, scalable, and sustainable water quality monitoring systems. These advancements will not only improve the precision of monitoring efforts but also enhance our ability to address global water quality issues effectively. As we move forward, the integration of computational methods with environmental management will play a critical role in ensuring safe and sustainable water for generations to come.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is water quality monitoring?
Water quality monitoring involves measuring and assessing various physical, chemical, and biological parameters in water to determine its health and safety for human use, aquatic life, and ecosystems. It is essential for detecting pollutants, ensuring safe drinking water, and protecting the environment.
2. Why are computational methods important in water quality assessment?
Computational methods enhance the efficiency and accuracy of water quality monitoring. By using algorithms, machine learning, and real-time data collection systems, these methods allow for more comprehensive analysis, early detection of pollutants, and predictive modeling of water quality trends, providing timely and reliable information for decision-making.
3. What are some common water quality parameters monitored?
Common water quality parameters include physical factors such as temperature and turbidity, chemical factors such as pH, dissolved oxygen, and heavy metals, and biological factors such as microbial contamination and algal blooms. Monitoring these parameters helps to ensure the safety and health of water bodies.
4. How do sensors play a role in water quality monitoring?
Sensors are used to collect real-time data on various water quality parameters. They are deployed in water bodies to continuously monitor and transmit data, helping authorities quickly detect changes or contamination events. Sensors are crucial for gathering accurate, up-to-date information that is essential for effective water management.
5. What are the main challenges of using computational methods in water quality monitoring?
Some of the main challenges include data quality and availability, as sensor calibration and data integration can be difficult. Algorithm accuracy and the reliability of predictive models are also critical concerns. Additionally, environmental factors, such as temperature variations and external interferences, can affect the accuracy of results.
6. What emerging technologies are improving water quality assessment?
Emerging technologies such as nanotechnology, smart water sensors, remote sensing, and AI-powered tools are significantly improving water quality assessment. These technologies provide higher sensitivity, real-time monitoring, and the ability to analyze large datasets more effectively, leading to better predictions and faster responses to pollution events.
7. How do predictive models help in water quality management?
Predictive models use historical data to forecast future water quality conditions. These models can predict contaminant levels, identify potential pollution events, and assist in managing water resources more efficiently. By anticipating changes in water quality, authorities can take proactive measures to protect public health and the environment.
8. Can computational methods address global water quality issues?
Yes, computational methods are playing an increasingly important role in addressing global water quality issues. By using advanced tools such as big data analytics, remote sensing, and AI, we can monitor water quality over large regions, identify pollution sources, and develop strategies for more sustainable water management worldwide.
References
- Water Quality: An Introduction – Claude E. Boyd – 2015 – Springer
- Water Quality Monitoring: A Practical Guide to the Design and Implementation of Freshwater Quality Studies and Monitoring Programs – Jamie Bartram, Richard Ballance – 1996 – CRC Press
- Water Quality Assessments: A Guide to the Use of Biota, Sediments and Water in Environmental Monitoring – Deborah Chapman – 1996 – UNESCO/WHO/UNEP
- Fundamentals of Environmental Sampling and Analysis – Chunlong Zhang – 2007 – John Wiley & Sons
- Statistical Methods in Water Resources – D.R. Helsel, R.M. Hirsch – 2002 – U.S. Geological Survey
- Artificial Intelligence in Water and Wastewater Treatment – R. Hanbay, B. Turkoglu – 2021 – Elsevier
- Environmental Modelling: Finding Simplicity in Complexity – John Wainwright, Mark Mulligan – 2013 – Wiley-Blackwell
- Remote Sensing and GIS for Environmental Studies – P.S. Roy, R.S. Dwivedi, D.P.Rao – 2010 – Indian Institute of Remote Sensing